Obtained: The publisher provided me with an advance copy for review.
The Plot: Following the events of Blood Moon the characters of Willa and Simon are spending a lot of their free time training as hard as possible to pass the first test to becoming a True Witch. The Covenant they have joined have taken up residence in Twelve Acres so that they can all be close together as Willa and Simon continue realizing their full potential.
The trouble is that Simon is plagued by nightmares and other secrets he either doesn’t know the truth about or that he doesn’t want to share with Willa. On the other hand, Willa has been delving deeper and deeper into the mystery that is Simon and his multiple schools of magic when other witches are only gifted with a single school. The answers she uncovers are startling and reveal that Simon may have a destiny much more grand than anyone in the Covenant had dared to imagine in the short time they have all been together.
Meanwhile, Archard, the Dark witch from Blood Moon is not as dead as everyone had hoped and he’s delving into some twisted, dark, and intensely powerful magic from the old teachings of Bartholomew the Dark, the last Dark witch to successfully form a Dark Covenant, the same one that brought about what the common folk know as the Dark Ages.
The Commentary: After my reading of Blood Moon, the first book in The Moonlight Trilogy, I was on the fence about whether or not I really wanted to continue with the second book. These books are treading ground in the very new genre of “New Adult” and it sits far to the side of my usual reading habits. However, the publisher very kindly asked me to review the book and a longtime friend of mine happens to be the editor for these books as well. Thankfully, my friend was able to tell me my misgivings about Blood Moon were something that I would not have with Black Moon if I just sat down and got to reading.
As it turns out, he was completely right.
My biggest misgiving previously was feeling that the Light witches had no real sense of danger surrounding them. It felt like it was a forgone conclusion that they were going to win and none of them were going to come to any harm. In Black Moon all of that changes. The danger the Light Covenant faces is much more real and the consequences of their actions are not always immediately apparent. With that out of the way, the book really slid into place for me and I was able to get into the story much more thoroughly than before.
I was also very impressed with Black Moon’s treatment of the relationship between Simon and Willa. In the first book it was immediately established that they are soul mates, but relationships in real life are a lot more complicated than that even if you have found the person you want to be with for the rest of your life. Teri Harman does an amazing job making sure that Simon and Willa aren’t just love-struck, star-crossed lovers. They may only be around twenty years old, but they are mature enough to realize that they don’t actually know everything about each other; that they will actually have to sit down and talk about things instead of just taking each other’s actions for granted because they are in love.
Most authors aren’t willing to have their two characters have a big fight and let it simmer for a while. They all want an immediate makeup scene. Teri Harman is willing to let Simon and Willa be mad at each other. She’s willing to let them act like people do in real life where they get pissed off and have to leave the house for an hour or two to calm down before coming back and still being angry, but finally calm enough to talk about things. It’s a very fresh change of pace compared to most relationships in books.
There is a pretty big plot twist toward the end of Black Moon that I had figured out around the halfway point, but while I may have had the twist figured out, I absolutely did not have the person it was going to happen to figured out. That spun me for a loop and I have to give props to Teri Harman for taking me by surprise. I pride myself on my ability to pick up on foreshadowing and other similar things rather well, so pulling a fast one on me is always impressive.
Worth It? Yes. If you have read Blood Moon, the first book of the trilogy, you will certainly want to read this one because it continues the story in a very satisfying fashion. If you haven’t read the first book, you could probably still pick up Black Moon and not find yourself too lost because the author does a good job of keeping the reader up to speed. Black Moon is carving into new ground genre-wise, so it might be a little different from what the average YA reader is expecting, but that isn’t a bad thing, I promise.
Left Me Wanting… Just a little bit more action. The very fresh genre of “new adult” is something that sits on the fringes of my typical reading tastes, and I understand why Black Moon isn’t packed with action like my typical fare, but I felt the story lent itself to just a little bit more. Black Moon does have much more action than Blood Moon, and that made me happy, but it still fell just a tiny bit short of the perfect amount in my opinion.
Want a chance at a free copy of Black Moon to read for yourself? Head on over to the Rafflecopter Giveaway the publisher is hosting and see if you can get lucky!